Five Common Mistakes on Geology Field Trips and How to Avoid Them

Five Common Mistakes on Geology Field Trips and How to Avoid Them

A good geology field trip is a small act of detective work. You arrive with a question — why are these beds folded, where did this sandstone come from, what is that green mineral? — and you leave with evidence. Most outings that go wrong do so for reasons that have nothing to do with the rocks. They go wrong before anyone lifts a hammer.

Here are the five mistakes I see most often, and the habits that prevent them. None of it is exotic. All of it is easier to fix in the car park than halfway up a cliff.

1. Setting off without checking the ground rules

The first mistake is treating access, weather and tides as background detail. They are the trip.

Before you go, find out who owns the land and whether you are allowed on it. In the UK, many of the best exposures sit on farmland, in working quarries, on foreshores, or within Sites of Special Scientific Interest, where collecting may be restricted or need consent from the relevant conservation body. It takes ten minutes to check, and it is the difference between a welcome and a locked gate next time.

Then work through the practicalities:

  • Tide times for coastal sections, and how much cliff or how many rocky coves lie between you and the way out.
  • The forecast, including wind, and how quickly wet ground will turn greasy underfoot.
  • Sunset, and how long the walk back actually takes rather than how long you hope it takes.
  • Whether anyone at home knows your route and expected return time.

Tell someone where you are going. Charge your phone, but carry a paper map as well; signal on a coastal path is not a plan.

Safety is not a lecture

Hard hat near any cliff or quarry face. Eye protection whenever you swing a hammer. Gloves for broken ground, and boots with ankle support. Never work directly beneath an overhang, and never hammer into rock above your head, because splinters travel further than you expect. If a face looks unstable, stay back, use a lens or binoculars, and take photographs instead. On remote ground, a small first-aid kit and a spare layer are worth the weight in the rucksack.

2. Collecting first and thinking second

The hammer comes out too early. A fresh break destroys the very thing you came to see: the weathered surface, the cross-bedding on top of the bed, the trace fossil running along the bedding plane. Read the exposure first. Photograph it, sketch it, describe it — then decide whether a sample is actually needed.

Then be selective. A dozen well-chosen specimens with good labels beat thirty random lumps. Prefer loose material: scree, beach cobbles, spoil heaps. Leave the best example in place for the next visitor, and never chip at a site's only exposure of a key feature. Do not collect from walls, buildings or drystone dykes, however tempting the stone.

On a guided trip or a field course, follow the leader's instructions about what may be collected. On private land, ask before you take anything and offer to show the owner what you found. It keeps the door open for everyone.

3. Field notes that make no sense a week later

This is the quiet killer. You get home with a bag of rocks and a notebook reading "grey limestone, near the bend" — and by then you cannot remember which bend, or which way up the bed was.

If your notes do not tell you where a sample came from, the sample is a paperweight.

Record as you go, not at the end of the day. A pencil survives rain; a pen does not. For every locality, note:

  1. Date, time, weather and who was with you.
  2. A grid reference or a marked point on the map, plus a plain description of the spot.
  3. What you can see: rock type, colour, grain size, structures, fossils, contacts with neighbouring units.
  4. Orientation — strike and dip, or the direction and angle of the beds — and the instrument you used.
  5. Which sample number came from which point on the exposure.

Sketches beat adjectives. Draw the face with a north arrow and a scale: a lens cap, a coin, a rucksack. Photographs help, but add a scale and write down the direction you were facing, otherwise you will spend the evening working out what you were looking at.

Label the sample, not just the bag

Write the sample number and locality on a slip of paper or a strip of masking tape and put it inside the bag with the rock. Bags get separated, ink rubs off, and a bag of unlabelled specimens is just gravel. If orientation matters, draw the strike and dip arrow directly onto the specimen while it is still in your hand.

4. Missing the context by staring at the specimen

Field geology is about relationships. A rock in isolation tells you very little; the same rock in contact with the unit above it tells you a story about time.

So look up and out. Note the thickness of beds, how they change along the exposure, the faults and veins cutting across them, the way the cliff face alters as you walk. Ask what lies above, below and beside. That is where the interpretation lives.

Watch for way-up evidence while you are standing there: graded bedding, cross-bedding, ripple marks, load casts. You cannot recover it later from a photograph you did not take.

5. Trying to do too much

The last mistake is ambition. Four localities in a day, with an hour's drive between each, means four rushed stops and shallow notes. Two well-worked sites will teach you more, and you will remember them.

Build in time to sit, eat and look at the view without a hammer in your hand. Some of the best observations happen when nobody is hurrying.

A short pre-trip checklist

Before you leave: permission and site designation checked; tides, weather and daylight confirmed; route left with someone at home; boots, hard hat, eye protection, gloves, first-aid kit and waterproofs packed; notebook, pencil, map, compass or clinometer, camera and sample bags in the rucksack.

In the field: look and write before you break anything; record location, orientation and context; label every sample; take only what you need; leave the site as you found it.

Do that, and you will come home with something better than a heavy bag — a set of observations you can actually use.

Photo: eliasfalla / Pixabay

Related Posts